JPMorgan Sued for Including ‘Underperforming’ Stable Value Fund in 401(k) Menu

Ironwood Retirement Plan Consultants • March 24, 2025

The company was accused of using an in-house stable value investment that underperforms competitors.

A former employee of JPMorgan Chase Bank N.A. filed a complaint against the company last week, arguing that a stable value investment in the bank’s 401(k) plan performed poorly when compared with other available stable value funds.


In Gonzalez v. JPMorgan Chase Bank N.A. et al., filed in U.S. District Court for the District of New Jersey, plaintiff Alexandro Gonzalez claimed that JPMorgan Chase Bank failed to objectively and adequately review the plan’s investment offerings, initially and on an ongoing basis, with due care to ensure each investment option was prudent in terms of performance.


As of the end of 2023, the plan had more than $44 billion in assets under management and 295,407 participants. Gonzalez’s complaint argues that, as a jumbo plan, the plan had substantial bargaining power regarding the fees and expenses charged against participants’ investments.


According to the lawsuit, fiduciaries at JPMorgan allowed substantial assets in the 401(k) plan to be invested in the JPMorgan Stable Value Fund that invested in synthetic guaranteed investment contracts offered by MetLife, Prudential Financial, Transamerica and Voya Financial.

GICs are issued by insurance companies in the form of a fixed annuity contract.


“A prudent fiduciary would not have included this underperforming investment option that also carried significantly more risk than other investment options that had similar goals, i.e., preservation of investment assets,” the complaint states.


The complaint also states that a more prudent fiduciary could have demanded higher crediting rates from the insurance companies by submitting requests for proposals to the insurance companies and other providers of stable value investments.


In addition, the plaintiff alleges that the insurance companies “benefited significantly” from participants in the plan investing in the stable value fund. The complaint states that the crediting rates the insurance companies provided to the plan “were and are so low that the insurance companies reaped a windfall on the spread.”

The complaint also accuses JPMorgan of failing to monitor its investment committee to ensure that it was adequately performing its fiduciary obligations under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act.


The plaintiff is asking the court to declare that JPMorgan breached its fiduciary duties under ERISA and order the company both to disgorge all profits received from the plan and to make good on all plan losses resulting from “imprudent investment of the plan’s assets,” among other demands.

Gonzalez is represented by law firm Capozzi Adler P.C. in the case.

JPMorgan declined to comment on the lawsuit.


The bank was also sued last week by current and former health plan participants who allege the company mismanaged the prescription drug benefit under its health insurance offering.


Source: https://www.plansponsor.com/jpmorgan-sued-for-underperforming-stable-value-fund-in-401k-menu/

Reported by:

By Ironwood Retirement Plan Consultants April 4, 2025
A new survey shows 67% of investors aren’t spending any time on retirement planning each month—including over half of those nearing retirement. This blog highlights the growing engagement gap and offers ideas for how plan sponsors can help participants get back on track.
By Ironwood Retirement Plan Consultants April 4, 2025
More retirees are choosing to keep their 401(k) assets in their employer’s plan after retirement, according to a recent Fidelity report. This article explores the reasons behind this trend—such as lower fees, familiar investment options, and improved retirement income solutions—and what it means for plan sponsors looking to better support retirees.
By Ironwood Retirement Plan Consultants April 1, 2025
In this month’s Retirement Times, we explore how plan sponsors can use internal data to drive smarter decisions and improve retirement outcomes. Plus, we take a closer look at the retirement planning engagement gap and offer strategies to help participants take meaningful action.
By Ironwood Retirement Plan Consultants March 28, 2025
As tax laws evolve and personal financial situations change, it's essential to stay informed about strategies that can help minimize your tax burden. Here are several tips to consider.
By Ironwood Retirement Plan Consultants March 24, 2025
The defendants claim the company breached its ERISA fiduciary duty by putting business interests ahead of the plan and its participants.
By Ironwood Retirement Plan Consultants March 20, 2025
Many people often find that they know far less about their retirement plan than they thought. Test yourself with the quiz below and see how much you know about your financial future.
By Ironwood Retirement Plan Consultants March 12, 2025
Leveraging your employer’s retirement plan match is one of the easiest ways to boost your financial wellness. With over 50% of employers offering some level of matching, it’s an opportunity you don’t want to miss. Here’s how to make the most of it.
By Ironwood Retirement Plan Consultants March 1, 2025
Get expert insights and actionable strategies to navigate today’s retirement landscape.
By Ironwood Retirement Plan Consultants February 17, 2025
The rise of part-time and gig workers has reshaped the labor market—but what does this mean for retirement plan participation? Many employers are navigating the complexities of including part-time employees in workplace retirement benefits. With evolving regulations and shifting workforce trends, it’s crucial to stay ahead. This article breaks down the impact of part-time employees on retirement plans and offers strategic insights for plan sponsors.
By Ironwood Retirement Plan Consultants February 10, 2025
Employer 401(k) matching contributions are one of the most powerful tools for building long-term financial security—yet many workers leave these dollars on the table. Why?
More Posts
Share by: